Shinyo (Trust) and the Japanese
One of the most important concepts in daily life in Japan is shinyo (SHIN-yo), which means "trust," and when Japanese have dealings with individuals or businesses, choosing someone they can trust is extremely important. Of course, everyone wants to deal with people and companies they believe will do right by them, but in Japanese society the idea of only working with trustworthy entities is elevated to a much higher cultural level. One way to make sure you're working with people you can trust is the concept of shokai (SHO-kai), a kind of introduction whereby someone who is already trusted by a third party will formally introduce you to them, in effect sharing the goodwill they've already established with both you and the third party. Because both parties have a trust relationship involved, they have an obligation to make sure everything goes smoothly to avoid "stepping on the face" (to use the Japanese phrase) of the person that brought you together. There isn't a single aspect of Japan that isn't improved by this trust-based relationship system, and time and time again I've found myself depending on people who had been formally introduced to me by someone else I trusted. My wife recently sold her car through a used car dealer, and I happened to remark that it was odd that cars are seldom sold between individuals in Japan -- there's no local version of the Auto Trader or eBay Motors. The reason, I was told, was that no one would ever be able to trust a stranger enough to buy a car, since they might be lied to about important details or otherwise taken advantage of, so they instead rely on professional companies whose reputations they can verify, of course paying more for the privilege.




4 Comments:
Trust is one major factor when reselling cars and I can see that it's a much safer bet to go through a dealer than to buy off an individual directly. Although I don't know how the user car market works in Japan, but one thing for sure is that you'll miss getting bargains by buying from an individual.
6:21 AM
I don't know, I always bought my cars directly back when I lived in the U.S. and bought used cars. It was fun to bring $500 less than the asking price in cash in an envelope and see if you could get the price down by offering cash on the spot. Usually it worked.
12:11 PM
I've reached a point in my career where I find jobs through people I trust rather than by applying for jobs blind. It sounds like much the same process, offering the same protections.
Now, why is it that if you drop your wallet on a park bench in Japan, you could go back three days later and probably find it still there -- but the level of honor that implies doesn't extend to buying a car from an individual?
8:18 PM
Good point, Jim, glad to hear it works in the U.S. too. I guess the idea of a "referral" is similar to a "shokai" type of introduction. As for having wallets returned, that's probably a different kind of honesty, i.e. the individual making the decision to turn the wallet into the police or whatever, rather than having to put your trust in someone else, especially when it's a car that might be mechanically damaged without the other party knowing about it, etc. Once I did sell a motorcycle I owned here to a Japanese man, and I remember my wife sending it off to a mechanic to make sure the brakes and gears were all replaced and brand new so that there was no danger to the person buying the bike from us. Not sure if it's done completely out of wanting to protect the person completely or wanting to make sure we were protected from any possible accusation that we'd sold him a motorcycle that wasn't in perfect shape.
10:32 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home