Manga and Learning Japanese
Naturally, the Japanese that's taught in textbooks isn't always the most natural-sounding, and I remember being frustrated by some of the language I was learning at college, which seemed to be too formal to me. I augmented my own studies by reading lots of manga in Japanese, a great way to expose one's self to the language as it's spoken since nearly all of what's written on the page is character dialogue, which gave me a model to use when speaking myself. (Plus reading manga is fun.) I'll never forget how taken aback my teacher was when I first asked her for help in understanding what I was reading in the comics, though: "That is not Japanese! You should not read it!" she said, refusing to even answer the question I had. Now looking back, I can understand her position somewhat, since when learning a foreign language it's important to avoid being rude when using words you might not understand completely, and erring on the side of politeness is never a bad idea. I certainly have offended more than one Japanese person by using all those cool words I learned from Fist of the North Star on them. The question I'd tried to ask my teacher back then was certainly one that would never have appeared in any textbook: it was the colloquialism tte, that is, a small pause and the syllable te, which is put on the ends of words or sentences. It's meaning can be quite complex, but it usually corresponds to "he said" or "or so I've heard." For example, if you are telling someone that you've heard this parfait shop is good, you can add tte to the end of a sentence, i.e. kono mise wa oishii tte, meaning, "They tell me that this shop is really delicious."




9 Comments:
Times must have changed, as I have been taught (briefly) about ...って in my Japanese classes.
11:55 PM
Ah, maybe so. She was especially strict I think. And yet, she was so damn hot, the object of everyone's fantasy. I think she was 25 at the time, which seemed like such an experienced age for a woman to be when I was 18. Bwa ha ha.
1:05 AM
Learned my lesson when they tried to teach me Spanish in school, trying to make me sound like a goddamn missionary. Perhaps I should get some formal instruction, but I probably run into your problem of teachers trying to make you sound like some heiress girl.
2:08 AM
manga? try sundome.
4:05 PM
Is it good, Timo? I haven't had time for manga in an age, what a shame since I like it. I usually watch the anime versions of what I want to see, and if the manga is much more extensive I read it, like Genshiken, which you have to read since the anime is incomplete.
7:34 PM
Lol, at least she wsa not like my English teacher in high-school, when I asked for a sentence I read in a D&D rules book she didn't even know that that meant.
2:22 AM
I remember covering the colloquial "って" in my Japanese class. There was a whole paragraph about it in the textbook, called Nakama, that I used.
Also Peter, I just recently got my hands on the Genshiken manga, true that about the anime being incomplete. But when you think about it, its not uncommon for that to happen when something is adapted to video, be it a novel or a manga. I don't know how many anime have destroyed their source material (thats you anime version of Zero no Tsukaima), at least the anime version of Genshiken was still very enjoyable.
9:19 PM
Yes, I didn't expect Genshiken to be so thoroughly satisfying in all ways, funny considering it's 地味 story, i.e. not flashy like Eva or whatever. I feel sorry for Welcome to the NHK since I expected something like Genshiken and it wasn't as good by far. (I didn't read the manga yet, I should do that.) Manga makes learning Japanese frankly something sort of close to easy, since it's so compelling in itself, it's not hard to study using manga.
10:43 PM
I have to agree with you about manga being a very compelling way to study. I love to study that way (its the reason I got Genshiken in the first place).
One of the first manga I read in Japanese was Yotsuba, another manga with a pretty "地味" story. I'd have to recommend it to anyone who wants to try studying by manga because of its simple story and the fact that all the kanji have their furigana over them. Its always good to start with a manga aimed at a younger audience.
11:41 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home