J-List is a wonderful toybox of things from Japan - come see
Every time you don't click over to J-List, God kills a kitten

The personal log of Peter Payne, owner of JLIST.com, the home of "wacky things from Japan"

Friday, July 10, 2009

Understanding Japan Through First and Second Pronouns

In the book Startide Rising by David Brin, humans have bio-engineered dolphins to be intelligent, and modified their spaceships so dolphin crews can work alongside humans in space. In the book, one dolphin remarks how amusing it is that humans bother to hide their feelings from members of the opposite sex; the sonar capabilities of dolphins allow them to see the internal changes in other dolphins and tell if one is interested in them physically, so there are never any secrets about who likes who. It was an interesting concept, and one that I sometimes think about in the context of Japan. In Japanese, people use different first- and second-person pronouns depending on how they perceive themselves and others, which sometimes betrays their intentions and their insecurities. For the pronoun "I" you could choose from watashi (formal, used more often by women), boku (semi-polite, usually used by younger males), and ore (OH-reh, mainly used by "manly" men); words for "you" include anata (formal, used by women more often than men); kimi (familiar, used by guys to their girlfriends or by anyone talking to a younger person); and omae (oh-MAH-eh, again, a "macho" sounding word generally used by males). This last word is especially interesting since it basically asserts the superiority of the speaker over the person he's addressing, a concept that doesn't exist in English. When a man uses the word omae to a female he's in a relationship with, the implication is that the girl "belongs to" him in a romantic sense, but a male using the word in other situations might indicate wishful thinking about how he wants others to view him. By paying attention to what pronouns people use, you can catch which guys are trying to act tougher than they feel and which girls are pretending to be more feminine than they are.

Most Japanese males will use the second person pronoun omae to show how manly they are.

4 Comments:

Blogger Kaoru Tayuu said...

Hi!!
That's very interesting! I'm from Sao Paulo, love japanese culture and despite reading a lot of things about it had no idea about that pronouns. Thanks for sharing! I'm glad I found your blog, it would be nice to read a diferent perspective from Japan, from someone who's not japanese!
Added to favorites!

7:30 PM

 
Blogger John Evans said...

I love the Uplift novels!...*ahem* Anyway, I've seen a couple places in anime where the pronouns add some insight into the story. For example, Rurōni Kenshin; Kenshin usually uses "boku", but the first time he goes into his murderous Battōsai personality, he uses "ore" instead. It tips off Kaoru (and the audience) that something is really different about him.

3:06 AM

 
Blogger Peter in Japan said...

Kaoru, welcome to the blog. Are you nikkei? It's an interesting aspect of Brazil to have so many people there of Japa Rae descent. In America, Hawaii has a lot of nikkei culture, but it's not really felt that much in the main US.

9:17 AM

 
Blogger Peter in Japan said...

John, yes, there's a ton of that. Like cherry boy Kyosuke trying to get enough self confidence to call Madoka yobisute, ie by name only without san, or by the last name. Or Godai, forcing himself to call Kyoko-san by her name, Kyoko, after their wedding, bow that they were finally equals. All impossible to express in English.

9:20 AM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

 


,